Should You Tell Your Boss You’re Job Hunting?

by , January 2, 2012 — 5 Comments
Should You Tell Your Boss You're Job Hunting?

You’ve had two interviews with a new company, and they’ve both gone extremely well. Now, you’ve been asked to come in for one “final” round. It’s only natural to feel optimistic—and to start planning how you’ll break the news to your current boss.

But even if everything’s looking promising, don’t start acting like you have the job until you have it. Sharing too much information about your job search early on can create an awkward situation for you—and for your boss.

Of course, it’s no secret to employers that, at any given time, their staff could be looking around, but there’s a big difference between your boss knowing you might be searching for a new job, and knowing for sure that you are.

I almost learned that lesson the hard way. Once, I’d been through three grueling in-person sessions, each with multiple people. I knew things were moving in the right direction, and the hiring manager was using phrases like “when you start, I’d like you to work on…” The company wanted me to come in one last time as a formality, which I assumed would be when they’d offer me the job.

So, naturally I bought a bottle of champagne and went home to draft my resignation letter, planning to hand it to my boss the next morning. But something stopped me—I was so eager to move on to the next opportunity, that I completely ignored the fact that I didn’t actually have the job yet.

JSM square Should You Tell Your Boss You’re Job Hunting?

I decided to hold off, and it’s a good thing I did. A few days later, after yet another stellar interview, I was informed the company had decided to go with another candidate. As it turned out, the CEO had a friend who’s daughter was looking for work, and she got the job.

If I’d submitted that resignation letter on first impulse, I would’ve put myself in the incredibly embarrassing position of having to retract my notice and beg to keep my job, not to mention deal with the distrust my boss would almost certainly harbor as a result of the fake-out.

As a manager, on the other side, I’ve unfortunately seen a few of my employees follow through on this mistake. Take this scenario: I once had an employee tell me she was about to start searching for a new job. She claimed she was simply giving me a heads-up, but I couldn’t help interpreting the situation as a poorly disguised threat. To me, it seemed the notification of her planned departure was a play for negotiating power, with her assuming (incorrectly) that I’d try to entice her to stay. In other words, I viewed her confession as an attempt to coerce me into paying her more.

The unintended consequence was that, from that point forward, I considered her a short-timer. I no longer trusted her to work on important projects for fear she would only complete a portion of the work, then serve me with another “heads-up” and attempt for a raise, knowing I couldn’t afford to lose her from the project. To this day, I have no idea if that woman’s intentions were altruistic or self-serving, but my impression of her was not a good one.

So when you’re starting your job search, think about the consequences before letting the cat out of the bag to your employer, and don’t do it preemptively. And more importantly, make sure you wait until you have an offer—in writing—before you hand in your letter of resignation. Even if you’ve nailed a few interviews, it could be a while before you actually leave, and your reputation and chance for a positive recommendation in the future could easily be damaged if you give notice before you’re really ready to quit.

Remember, how you leave your current job is just as important as how you start the next one. Breaking up is hard to do, but handle your search and your departure with consideration and respect for your soon-to-be-former employer, and chances are, you can still be friends.
 
 

Check out more from Job Search Month at The Daily Muse

 

Photo courtesy of David Castillo Dominici.

About the Author

Jennifer Winter is a freelance writer, editor and career consultant. She translates her 14-years of corporate combat experience to help others navigate their own careers, and become advocates for their own success. Need help negotiating that raise or writing the perfect email to your boss? Jennifer’s your girl. Find out more about her services on her blog, FearLessJenn or follow her on Twitter @fearlessjenn.

5 comments
Mike
Mike

I think it might be essential to be sure that the new place of employment is going to take you before you mention it to your coworkers/supervisors. After all, why get fired before you have a new income coming in?

Mike Allen
Mike Allen

You are an exception to the rule, and quite possibly a genius. In most cases, I know for certain that I will be fired if my boss gets proof that I am interviewing. A lessson I've learned over and over in life is that you cannot ever trust your supervisor, you cannot trust your colleagues, and you cannot trust your clients. You cannot trust anyone who might ever come in contact with your supervisor, which means there are some things I won't even tell my wife. This is a sad commentary on human nature, but I wasn't born with this opinion. I learned it the hard way on multiple occasions. What business are you in? I'd like to work for you.

Judy Dobles
Judy Dobles

I would like to offer another perspective for supervisors. During my career I have directly supervised over 100 people. During career planning sessions, I always encouraged my staff to look for positions on the outside of the company. If they do not benchmark themselves externally, they are limited in their knowledge. Then we would talk about what they found. What they would find, relative to their job responsibilities and pay is one of three things: [1] comparable to other companies, [2] higher than companies and [3] lower than other companies. If their salaries were comparable, they felt fairly treated and focused on how to improve their skills and gain additional responsibility. If their salareis were higher, they were keenly interested in how to significantly improve their skills. And if their pay was lower, we talked about the likelihood or not of achieving that at our company. In many cases, the individuals were capable but their internal competition was just a lot better. At another company, they could be a super star. In one such case, the individual left, received a significant salary increase and was very happy.

As a supervisor, the sooner I know someone is looking for a position, the quicker I can determine why and keep them in the company.

Being open is a two-way street. Employees need to feel that they can discuss their careers with their supervisors and not have that held against them.

Jennifer Winter
Jennifer Winter

Hi Helen,

This is definitely a challenge, however, I'd still say keep your plans under wraps as long as you can. Although I haven't done it myself, I imagine moving abroad can be somewhat complicated, which means your timeline may change (probably more than once) before you've actually booked your ticket. This means, if you say something too soon, you run that risk of still working with your employer knowing you're on your way out the door.

Chances are, your boss may already suspect your departure if you're taking unpaid leave, so no need to confirm her suspicions until you have something in writing. Take your time off and focus on those interviews!

Take it one step at a time, and as soon as you have that offer you can have a chat with your boss. Until then, you're just interviewing (albeit overseas)!

Good luck!!

Helen
Helen

Hi Jenn, Good advice, on both sides I would agree. However do you think he same advice applies if the employee is looking to move abroad? I am hoping to leave the uk for the states and may need to request unpaid leave to fly across for interviews. Is that still a no no? Not sure how I get around this one...